Making African Civil Society Work: Assessing Conditions for Democratic State-Society Relations in Rwanda

Authors

Fiacre BienvenuFollow

Document Type

Dissertation

Degree

Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)

Major/Program

Political Science

First Advisor's Name

John F. Clark

First Advisor's Committee Title

Chair and Advisor

Second Advisor's Name

Tatiana Kostadinova

Second Advisor's Committee Title

Committee Member

Third Advisor's Name

Erin K. Damman

Third Advisor's Committee Title

Committee Member

Fourth Advisor's Name

Jean M. Rahier

Fourth Advisor's Committee Title

Committee Member

Keywords

Civil Society, Africa, Democracy, Democratization, Rwanda, Political Culture, State-Society Relations

Date of Defense

4-26-2018

Abstract

This dissertation offers a single case in-depth analysis of factors precluding civil society from democratizing African polities. Synthesizing existing literature on Rwanda, I first undertake an historical search to trace the origins and qualities of civil society in the colonial era. This effort shows, however, that the central authority—commencing before the inception of the Republic in 1962—consistently organized civil society to buttress its activities, not to challenge them. Next, using ethnographic research, I challenge conventional economic and institutional accounts of civil society’s role in democratization. I show that institutional change and the economic clout of organized groups are marginal and transient in effect, and hence possess considerable limitations to democratize state and non-state-groups relations. I argue that the Genocide and its historical materials, social and economic precariousness, and neo-patrimonial power configurations have erected a prevailing political culture that still conditions how Rwanda’s state-society relations are imagined, realized, and challenged. Conversely, just as that political culture has lengthened the reach of the state into society, limiting the potential autonomy of civil society, it has also been the basis for rebuilding the society, restoring the state’s authority, and enacting major state-building oriented reforms. Consequently, for CSOs to induce a liberal democratic order in domestic politics, subsequent activism will require long-term strategic and organic investment of actors into the dispersed, parochial strands of democracy first, not into ongoing confrontational, yet fruitless, political warfare that hinders social capital formation and that civil society is not yet equipped to win.

Identifier

FIDC006571

Recommended Citation

Bienvenu, Fiacre, "Making African Civil Society Work: Assessing Conditions for Democratic State-Society Relations in Rwanda" (2018). FIU Electronic Theses and Dissertations. 3822.
https://digitalcommons.fiu.edu/etd/3822