Impacts of U.S. Immigration Detention and Transfers on the Well-Being of Those Detained Within a Punitive For-Profit System
Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)
Global and Sociocultural Studies
First Advisor's Name
First Advisor's Committee Title
Second Advisor's Name
Second Advisor's Committee Title
Third Advisor's Name
Third Advisor's Committee Title
Fourth Advisor's Name
Fourth Advisor's Committee Title
Immigration, Immigration Detention, Transfers, Critical Medical Anthropology, Mobility
Date of Defense
The United States has the largest detention infrastructure in the world, with over 250 official detention centers and over 1,000 partner facilities. This research project aimed to analyze the U.S. immigration detention system to understand how the history of U.S. immigration and U.S. social structures like immigration law and detention practices, specifically transfers, affect immigrants. Woven into U.S. detention practices is a long history of exploitive and racist policies that have scapegoated new waves of immigrants since the late 1800s, which evolved toward the criminalization of immigrants in the mid-1990s.
One of the contributions of this dissertation is its focus on transfers – the movement of detainees between detention centers – as these are a growing detention practice and are often excluded from media coverage and immigration literature. This dissertation demonstrates how transfers contribute significantly to the maintenance of the deportation regime and the trauma and emotional effects of detention. It also analyzes the motivations behind transfers, including the operational, financial, strategic, and punitive incentives that drive these movements of detainees.
Fifteen (15) semi-structured interviews were conducted with detainees following their
Qualitative interviews allowed participants to express, in their own words, their experiences of immigration detention, particularly the effects of transfers between detention centers, and the impacts that detention practices had on them physically and psychologically.
This research provides testimony that immigration detention transfers indisputably increase the suffering and negative impacts of detention on detainees’ overall well-being. In their narratives, the participants reported inhumane conditions and human rights violations and expressed their fear of being transferred. They also illustrated instances where transfers were used punitively, confirming that Immigration and Customs Enforcement fails to follow many of its own standards and regulations regarding transfers. Transfers are one more component of the immigration industry that prioritizes profit over human rights.
Ending immigrant detention is the ultimate solution to eliminate the trauma faced by detainees. This dissertation offers alternatives to detention and other recommendations that can be implemented to ameliorate immigrant experiences while detention continues.
Livingston, Karina J., "Impacts of U.S. Immigration Detention and Transfers on the Well-Being of Those Detained Within a Punitive For-Profit System" (2021). FIU Electronic Theses and Dissertations. 4748.
Geographic Information Sciences Commons, Human Geography Commons, Social and Cultural Anthropology Commons
In Copyright. URI: http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC/1.0/
This Item is protected by copyright and/or related rights. You are free to use this Item in any way that is permitted by the copyright and related rights legislation that applies to your use. For other uses you need to obtain permission from the rights-holder(s).