A Qualitative Study Examining Camaraderie and Conflict Between Female Academic Advisors in One Higher Education Institution
Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)
First Advisor's Name
Dr. Douglas Robertson
First Advisor's Committee Title
Second Advisor's Name
Dr. Daniel Saunders
Second Advisor's Committee Title
Third Advisor's Name
Dr. Sarah Mathews
Third Advisor's Committee Title
Fourth Advisor's Name
Dr. Rebekah Schulze
Fourth Advisor's Committee Title
Fifth Advisor's Name
Dr. Thomas Reio
Fifth Advisor's Committee Title
higher education, female staff, academic advisors, department climate, ethic of care, support, conflict
Date of Defense
Women in higher education face several challenges including visibility, chilly work climates, and barriers to leadership positions. Research on women in academia has focused on faculty and leadership and less on the female staff working service jobs, such as the role of the academic advisor. This interpretive qualitative study uses one-on-one interviews with eight full-time, female academic advisors working in a single, public, 4-year university.
The interviews revealed the experiences of women working in this role, explored their intradepartmental climates, their career aspirations, and the interactions they have with their female coworkers. The objective of the study was to take a closer look at their day-to-day working conditions, and the connections that are inevitably built in the office. Carol Gilligan’s theory on the ethic of care was used to frame the interpersonal relationships between the women, specifically to determine if the relationships were supportive or competitive in nature.
The results revealed that frequent face-to-face interactions between advisors, having a say in hiring decisions, and a shared space for advisors to work together all contributed to a positive department climate. Factors closely associated with conflict include an unclear pathway for promotion, limited opportunities to demonstrate leadership abilities, and having access to view and compare coworkers’ salaries. Factors associated with support included physical proximity, small-sized teams, and nurturing relationships between the advisors.
Lejarza, Alexandra C., "A Qualitative Study Examining Camaraderie and Conflict Between Female Academic Advisors in One Higher Education Institution" (2020). FIU Electronic Theses and Dissertations. 4433.
In Copyright. URI: http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC/1.0/
This Item is protected by copyright and/or related rights. You are free to use this Item in any way that is permitted by the copyright and related rights legislation that applies to your use. For other uses you need to obtain permission from the rights-holder(s).