A Methodological Framework for Modeling Pavement Maintenance Costs for Projects with Performance-based Contracts

Authors

Kamalesh Panthi, Florida International UniversityFollow

Document Type

Dissertation

Major/Program

Civil Engineering

First Advisor's Name

Syed M. Ahmed

First Advisor's Committee Title

Committee Chair

Second Advisor's Name

Luis Prieto-Portar

Third Advisor's Name

Arindam G. Chowdhury

Fourth Advisor's Name

M. Emre Bayraktar

Fifth Advisor's Name

Caesar Abi Shdid

Keywords

performance-based contracts, pavement, maintenance, cost estimation, transition probability matrix

Date of Defense

11-12-2009

Abstract

Performance-based maintenance contracts differ significantly from material and method-based contracts that have been traditionally used to maintain roads. Road agencies around the world have moved towards a performance-based contract approach because it offers several advantages like cost saving, better budgeting certainty, better customer satisfaction with better road services and conditions. Payments for the maintenance of road are explicitly linked to the contractor successfully meeting certain clearly defined minimum performance indicators in these contracts. Quantitative evaluation of the cost of performance-based contracts has several difficulties due to the complexity of the pavement deterioration process. Based on a probabilistic analysis of failures of achieving multiple performance criteria over the length of the contract period, an effort has been made to develop a model that is capable of estimating the cost of these performance-based contracts. One of the essential functions of such model is to predict performance of the pavement as accurately as possible. Prediction of future degradation of pavement is done using Markov Chain Process, which requires estimating transition probabilities from previous deterioration rate for similar pavements. Transition probabilities were derived using historical pavement condition rating data, both for predicting pavement deterioration when there is no maintenance, and for predicting pavement improvement when maintenance activities are performed. A methodological framework has been developed to estimate the cost of maintaining road based on multiple performance criteria such as crack, rut and, roughness. The application of the developed model has been demonstrated via a real case study of Miami Dade Expressways (MDX) using pavement condition rating data from Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) for a typical performance-based asphalt pavement maintenance contract. Results indicated that the pavement performance model developed could predict the pavement deterioration quite accurately. Sensitivity analysis performed shows that the model is very responsive to even slight changes in pavement deterioration rate and performance constraints. It is expected that the use of this model will assist the highway agencies and contractors in arriving at a fair contract value for executing long term performance-based pavement maintenance works.

Identifier

FI09120824

Recommended Citation

Panthi, Kamalesh, "A Methodological Framework for Modeling Pavement Maintenance Costs for Projects with Performance-based Contracts" (2009). FIU Electronic Theses and Dissertations. 120.
https://digitalcommons.fiu.edu/etd/120