Document Type
Dissertation
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)
Major/Program
Political Science
First Advisor's Name
John F. Stack
First Advisor's Committee Title
Committee Chair
Second Advisor's Name
Clement Fatovic
Third Advisor's Name
Eduardo Gamarra
Fourth Advisor's Name
Steven Heine
Keywords
Yanagita Kunio, John Stuart Mill, Marx, Japan, Nation-Building, Cultural Diversity, Culture and International Relations, Non-Western Political Thought
Date of Defense
10-26-2011
Abstract
The study examines the thought of Yanagita Kunio (1875-1962), an influential Japanese nationalist thinker best known as a founder of the discipline of Japanese folklore (minzokugaku). The purpose of the study is to bring into light an unredeemed potential of his intellectual and political project as a critique of the way in which modern politics and knowledge systematically suppresses global diversity. The study reads his texts against the backdrop of the modern understanding of space and time and its political and moral implications and traces the historical evolution of his thought that culminates in the establishment of minzokugaku.
My reading of Yanagita’s texts draws on three interpretive hypotheses. First, his thought can be interpreted as a critical engagement with John Stuart Mill’s philosophy of history, as he turns Mill’s defense of diversity against Mill’s justification of enlightened despotism in non-Western societies. Second, to counter Mill’s individualistic notion of progressive agency, he turns to a Marxian notion of anthropological space, in which a laboring class makes history by continuously transforming nature, and rehabilitates the common people (jōmin) as progressive agents. Third, in addition to the common people, Yanagita integrates wandering people as a countervailing force to the innate parochialism and conservatism of agrarian civilization. To excavate the unrecorded history of ordinary farmers and wandering people and promote the formation of national consciousness, his minzokugaku adopts travel as an alternative method for knowledge production and political education.
In light of this interpretation, the aim of Yanagita’s intellectual and political project can be understood as defense and critique of the Enlightenment tradition. Intellectually, he attempts to navigate between spurious universalism and reactionary particularism by revaluing diversity as a necessary condition for universal knowledge and human progress. Politically, his minzokugaku aims at nation-building/globalization from below by tracing back the history of a migratory process cutting across the existing boundaries. His project is opposed to nation-building from above that aims to integrate the world population into international society at the expense of global diversity.
Identifier
FI11120601
Recommended Citation
Kojima, Takehiko, "Diversity and Knowledge in the Age of Nation-Building: Space and Time in the Thought of Yanagita Kunio" (2011). FIU Electronic Theses and Dissertations. 495.
https://digitalcommons.fiu.edu/etd/495
Rights Statement
In Copyright. URI: http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC/1.0/
This Item is protected by copyright and/or related rights. You are free to use this Item in any way that is permitted by the copyright and related rights legislation that applies to your use. For other uses you need to obtain permission from the rights-holder(s).